[EDITION] TkK findings

[musicEnfanthen]

• M 317 Sk2.1: #path242 needs group element
• M 317 Sk2.1.2: m3, s2, 2/8: Red eighth flag in SVG

[musicEnfanthen]

M317

• M 317 Sk4 T. 3B-6:
  • doubled svgGroupId "g10030" for m. 6, sys. 3-4, and m. 6, sys. 4 ("fis1 durch Einkreisung getilgt"), probably wrong in second case
• M 317 Sk4 T. 7-12:
  • Missing tkk entry for tkk-group m. 12, sys. 8: [xx] ? Or too many classes? (order of svg elements)
• M 317 Sk4 T. 13-15:
  • Missing tkk entry for tkk-group m. 13, sys. 15,16: rests ? Or too many classes? (order of svg elements)
  • Missing tkk entry for tkk-group m. 14, sys. 16: [xx] ? Or too many classes? (order of svg elements)
• M317 Sk3.1.3:
  • Linkbox grouping for all link boxes missing?
  • In SVGs, this sketch includes system 5 (because of the "Strich mit unklarer Bedeutung."). Sys, 5 not declared in SourceDescription.
• M317 Sk3.1:
  • Nested tkk groups g1225 in g1241 works, but will not be rendered properly
  • Linkbox grouping for Sk1 missing
  • Link to C:Sk1 not correct (in comment for m. {5}, sys. 4, 6/8)
• M317 Sk3.1.2:
  • Linkbox grouping for Sk1 missing
• M317 Sk1:
  • Linkbox grouping for Sk2.1.3 missing

[masthom]

M 317 Sk 4, Missing tkk entry for tkk-group m. 14, sys. 16:
##looks fine to me. what is wrong?

M317 Sk3.1, Link to C:Sk1 not correct (in comment for m. {5}, sys. 4, 6/8):
##looks fine to me, what is wrong?

M317 Sk3.1.3, Linkbox grouping for all link boxes missing?:
##big mystery... grouping exists, sth is wrong anyway.

for the other findings in M317 see PR #852

[musicEnfanthen]

M 317 Sk 4, Missing tkk entry for tkk-group m. 14, sys. 16:
##looks fine to me. what is wrong?

The SVG viewer displays a tkk-box for "u. von u. 3 sowie Winkel mit rotem Buntstift." which is correct, but another (smaller) tkk-box inside it around the "u. 3". But there is no separate tkk for that location. So wether the tkk comment is missing or there is an additional misplaced tkk-class in the SVG file.

M317 Sk3.1, Link to C:Sk1 not correct (in comment for m. {5}, sys. 4, 6/8):
##looks fine to me, what is wrong?

Yes, seems to be fine for me, too. Probably there was some issue before the latest release, but it seems to be gone.

[masthom]

I see. M 317 Sk4 should be fixed now (update PR #852).

[masthom]

M317 Sk3.1.3, Linkbox grouping for all link boxes missing?:
##big mystery... grouping exists, sth is wrong anyway.

just a guess: this is the only item so far with linkbox grouping + "rowtable": true, might this cause the issue?

[musicEnfanthen]

I don't think so. But I recognized that in other files there is a group with an aria-label for the linkBox label within the g.link-box , something like:

<g
       aria-label="Sk2.1"
       id="text110"
       style="font-weight: 700; font-size: 12px; font-family: Arial-BoldMT, Arial;  isolation: isolate;  fill: #7d7d7d;"
       class="cls-13"> ...

This is missing for all link-boxes in Sk3.1.3

[musicEnfanthen]

M30 & M34

• M 34 Sk 1

  • Missing svgGroupId (and class in svg?) for m. 1, sys. 2, 3/4: Viertelnote gestrichen

• M 30 Sk1

  • T. {9D-12B}

    • m. {9D-12B} in SVG vs. m. {9D–10D, 11B}, 12B in sourceDesc

  • T. 7B -{10C}:

    • Des (?) in: {
      "svgGroupId": "g1156",
      "measure": "9C",
      "system": "11",
      "position": "1. Note",
      "comment": "des gestrichen."
      },

  • T. 9E-{15B}

    • {13B–15B} (?) in: {
      "svgGroupId": "g1197",
      "measure": "{13B–14B}",
      "system": "14–15",
      "position": "",
      "comment": "Takte pauschal gestrichen."
      },

  • T. 17–21

    • [b]b2 ... [a]g2 (?) in: {
      "svgGroupId": "g1131",
      "measure": "19",
      "system": "1",
      "position": "6/8",
      "comment": "b² überschreibt g²."
      },

  • T. 25–29B

    • [a]a1 ... [b]ges1(?) in: {
      "svgGroupId": "g1108",
      "measure": "27",
      "system": "7",
      "position": "4. Note",
      "comment": "a¹ überschreibt ges¹."
      },
    • class and groupId in SVG missing for {
      "svgGroupId": "g37",
      "measure": "{28A–29A}",
      "system": "7",
      "position": "",
      "comment": "Noten pauschal gestrichen."
      },

[musicEnfanthen]

M212 TF 1

• p. 1

  • The first tkk in m.1 has as location: (2/8) bis Taktende for the hairpin, but the crescendo hairpin ends at 2/4 ?

• p. 2

  • The tkk for m. 14, 1/8, and (now) m. 14 1/8 (but probably m. 23, see below) dispaly accidentals in brackets. Correct? //TA: correct!
  • There is no tkk displayed on the very last asterisk m. 23, but a second tkk displayed in m. 14, lower piano, that reads: 14 | Klav. | 1/8 | (♯) zu Gis1/Cis und (♮) zu H/g als redundant weggelassen. B: Akkoladenwechsel nach T. 22. which is probably the missing tkk for m. 23?

• SourceDescription:

  • Description mixes Flecke and Flecken for plural forms.
  • FirmSign mentioned, but no image/type included?
  • Die Korrekturen in <strong>B</strong>B betreffen Textfassung 2. Probably without the repeated B ? (ping @masthom since added after your PR)
  • Wouldn't add a line break in the title description

line breaks also in op. 25 source A (Taktzahlen, Instrumentenvorsatz)!?
for the other points see #910

• Tkk class and group id missing for

                   "svgGroupId": "",
                   "measure": "18",
                   "system": "Ges.",
                   "position": "1. Note",
                   "comment": "Text sic: (Ver-)storb(-nen) ohne Binnen-Apostroph. Rosegger_PM: Verstorb’nen."
               },

[musicEnfanthen]

Op. 22 SkRT

• SourceDescription:

  • Writing Material mentions 3 types of sheets, but refers only to "Bl. 1" and "Bl. 2"
  • Also: correct that the "shortest" sheet type has 9 systems, and the longer ones have only 8 systems?

• SkRTc

  • Last tkk on row variant 47 had: Bl. 3r | 8a | Ub. Corrected to Ud according to SourceDescription and transcription, correct?

[musicEnfanthen]

Op. 27 SkRT

• SkRTa:

  • Row form Ges should be Kgis (?) in
    Bl. 1r | 1b | Ges: 10.–11. Reihenton | Auf Rasur: vermutlich ♭b1–♮h1 geändert zu ♭b–♮h.

• SkRTb:

  • Tkk for second dividing line is missing (but duplicates svg id and content of that in SkRTa = C&P error?):
    Bl. 2r | 1b–8b | K- und KU-Formen: 6.–7. Reihenton | Strich zur Gliederung der Hexachorde mit rotem Buntstift. Vermutlich nachträglich gezogen, da der Strich mit einzelnen Notenköpfen kollidiert.
  • Kd should be Ka (?) in
    Bl. 2r | 1b | Kd | Reihennummerierung 18 mit grünem Buntstift.

[musicEnfanthen]

@chael-mi

M 37 Sk1

• SVG:

  • missing link-box class for linkBox to Sk1

• SourceDescription:

  • missing files for firmSign for sources A and B
  • correct order of sketches in sourceDescription?
  • wrong measure numbers for Sk2 and Sk3?

M 30 Sk1 (11/11)

• wrong measure numbers in link box labels (1-5 and 6-9 should be 1-4 and 5-9)

[musicEnfanthen]

@chael-mi

M 35/42

• SVGs for Sk1.1 and Sk2 missing

• TF1:

  • T. 14 = 23?
  • 1. Note = 1/4?

• Sk1b:

  • TkK for deleted D in m. {9A} missing

• Sk1d:

  • 16 = 16B?
  • TkK for deleted notes in m. {17B} missing
  • TkK for deletion m. 18 missing
  • supplied accid classes missing in some cases
  • linkbox to sk1 t.10-15 correct?

• Sk1e:

  • 22 = {22}?

• Sk2

• • Supplied clef (and key?) missing

• SourceDescription:

  • missing files for firmSign for sources B and D (m34 reused for A and C)

[musicEnfanthen]

@chael-mi

M 22

• Sk1:

  • m. 2, sys. 23: Fehlender Akkordhals?
  • m. 7, sys. 22, 1.-2. Note, commentary: "Oberstimmenschicht: " ?

• Sk2:

  • m .5, sys. 27, 3/4, commentary: "Viertelnote" tilgen?

• Sk3:

  • m. 3, sys. 26, 5/8, commentary: h1/d2 überschreibt a1/c2 [Viertelnote in Notentext ?]
  • m. 4, sys. 26, 2-3/16: Pause ergänzen?
  • m. 5B, sys. 26, 3/8: h2/h1 überschreibt a2?
  • m. 6, sys. 26, 2/4, commentary: "Unterstimmenschicht: " ?
  • m. 7, sys. 24: (5/8) statt 5/8 ?

• Sk4:

  • m. 8, sys. 19, 7/16: Überschreibung?

• Sk5: ----

• Sk6:

  • m. 4, sys. 15: Ergänzung # zu h? oder g (=[#]gis) gemeint?
  • m. 7, sys. 16, 4/8: Überschriebenes d2 = Achtelnote?

• Sk7: ----

• Sk8:

  • Darstellung von LinkBox zu Sk9 korrekt? Öffnung nach unten?

• Sk9:

  • m. {1A-2A}, commentary: "Takte"?

• Sk10: ---

• Sk11:

  • m. 6, sys. 5, 6/8, commentary: "Oberstimmenschicht:"?

• Sk12:

  • m. 3, sys. 3, 5–6/8: "(5–6/8)" or "5.–7. Note"?

• Sk13-16: ---

• Sk17:

  • m. 1, sys. 14, 4/16: A/a überschreibt c/c1. [= 3/8?]
  • m. 5, sys. 14, 1.–2. Note., commentary: E–e/e überschreibt Gis1/Gis–Gis/gis. [= "E–E/e überschreibt #Gis1/#Gis–Gis/gis." ?]

• Sk18:

  • m. 2, sys. 16, 16 [= "1. Note"?]
  • m. 7, sys. 13, 2.–3. Note [= "[2.-3. Note]"? ], commentary: a–f1 überschreibt d2–a1. [= "a1–f1 überschreibt d2–a1."?]

• Sk19: ---

• Sk20:

  • Schlüssel und Vorzeichnung zusammen klammern?

• Sk21:

  • m. {1A} | 17–18 | (1/4) | Noten gestrichen. [= "{1A} | | | Takt pauschal gestrichen."?]
  • m. 2, sys. 18, 1–2/8: E–g überschreibt Gis–h. [= E-[#]gis?]
  • m. 2, sys. 18, 5/8: gis überschreibt h. [kein ergänztes Akzidenz im Notentext?]
  • Vgl. auch Anmerkung m. 3

• Sk22: ---

• Sk23:

  • 1/1: Linkbox zu Sk23.1 = Sk23 T. 7?
  • m. 1, sys. 3, Taktanfang: Bassschlüssel überschreibt Violinschlüssel?
  • m. 7, sys. 4: Ort im Takt bei beiden Tkk uneindeutig? 1/4 = (1/4)?; 2/8 = (3/8)?

• Sk24:

  • m. 7, sys. 1, 2. Note, commentary: "E/gis/h/e1" [= e/gis/h/e1?]; "sic. lies: ..." [= sic; lies: ...?]

• Sk25:

  • 2/2: Darstellung von LinkBox zu Sk26 T. 5 korrekt? Besser "Sk26 T. 1–5"? Öffnung nach unten?

• Sk26:

  • m. 1, sys. 8, 5/8: h überschreibt c2. [= h1?]
  • m. 8, sys. 11, 6–7/8 [= 6–7/16?]
  • 2/2: Darstellung von LinkBox zu Sk27 T. 4–6 korrekt? Besser "Sk27"? Öffnung nach unten?

• Sk27/Sk27.1: ---

• Sk28

  • m. {2A}: Oberstimmenschicht: Ort im Takt: "1. Note" korrekt?
  • m. 5, sys. 14, 1. Pause: Punktierte Achtelnote [= Punktierte Achtelpause?]
  • m. 7, sys. 9, (2/4): c1/a überschreibt a/e. [= "c1-a überschreibt a-e" ?]

• Sk29:

  • m. 8, sys. 2, 1–3/4: Noten gestrichen. -> alle?

• Sk30: ---

• Sk31:

  • SVG Titel: "T. 8" fehlt
  • 2/2: "M 22" von LinkBox zu Sk28.1 tilgen

• Sk32: ---

• Sk32.1:

  • SVG: 8A [= {8A}?]
  • "M 22" von LinkBox zu Sk32.1.1 tilgen

• Sk32.1.1:

  • SVG, header: 32.1 = 32.1.1 ?

• Sk33:

  • m. 5 bis 6, sys. 14, letzte Note 1. Note: "Unterstimmenschicht: f1 überschreibt g1 in T. 6; Ligatur zu g1 in T. gestrichen." [= in T. 6?]
  • m. 6, sys. 14, 3/4: Mittelstimmenschicht: f2 überschreibt h1. [= [a]h1?]
  • m. 8, sys. 14, 3/4: Oberstimmenschicht [=Mittelstimmenschicht?]

[musicEnfanthen]

@chael-mi

M 36

• Sk1:
  • m. 6, sys. 16: 16 = 17? Metrisch falsch gesetzter [r statt n?]

"6	16	3/4	Metrisch falsch gesetzten Notenkopf e gestrichen."

• m. 12: Viertelpause und unsichere Viertelnote überschreiben Halbe Note?

"12	12	2/4	Entzifferung unsicher. Die Viertelnote ..."

• m. 16, Kommentar fehlt?

[musicEnfanthen]

@chael-mi

M 38

• Sk2:

  • Link-Boxes in SVG verweisen auf M 37 Sk2 und Sk3, müsste aber Sk1 und Sk2 sein

• Sk3

  • zweites SVG müsste im Titel haben: "T. 5"; hat aber "T. 1-4" wie erstes SVG