Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Gear Compare does not apply settings from custom footers in expert mode properly. #439

Closed
mahranaka opened this issue Jan 17, 2024 · 1 comment

Comments

@mahranaka
Copy link

mahranaka commented Jan 17, 2024

Describe the bug
Simulating via expert mode with custom footers from the MDT-sim export does work on Top-Gear and Droptimizer sims. If i send the same sim in a Gear Compare it results in much lower DPS. If we look at the html report that we can view in gear compare it shows that the pulls only last 10-20 seconds which is waay too low for a key level 28 sim. The Gear Compare does not seem to properly apply the settings from the weakauras export.

For reference:
Weakaura used to create the export: https://wago.io/Yya4XBbl-

MDT Dungeon route import for reference:
!9vvxR1nmm0FqJcXXXF9A3OWyqwPUmy7btV3BCkz1nPKRtx3l93(SKDsCsVm460elPJo6yzvdXCVr30122DAY5)RPUuA0tDngT7NhVtZhf)6PVz0hAAg6)HD8C3qVPUIslm6tdUHXBp4SEV9R9TdashM8dFg2VR)rZ178P5TqOgVr)6b3KfC)S1zp5bmV3utm1CW6PPXrBVxpD0zF16ad6xMCUZrNwFa)kdpPMAk(wf8IhED2Uh25(zplrhPjdvzEfjQr32sTTTlyW2KOnyxMffeJYc0p3DWJ18hTOqlsKecKW8CqfOz(ocrTRmrebf5E5gqjfGb5mfyXn55saBdNvqLUaSkcm(Pi8iHv4pe5ffQ2JaVuzq7JkqUQaUiYpnKxsIezrbXaAPCPLaCKfp2kqjtHFtqLQMGWQIuDov0iUYDSbQ3agBzqQLOc)XIvYcqvB4CSlJufrxTH1kuoiQSI1NY2kfWMlaG12DOo2ljqrnxiygZAWJKuI1Uc7y29jisHmayah)Oorer2hokJ2aFy)hFyyPuxcPTiTiPvzAb2QslwAXtlrCrsDvy9mldhiX(IsYoTQCxBaQv7V(6r29XR0SK64nR6B6GcXy)DvY8rSebrKbcpfwegr2fK1uFP7Ol5fBHi8SMX16yMtSnCkExSSyJISol8lt9pAh6ttq1ER9zya7XfhUnmFeiLESR1)922ZwpoUmEfgHYBFl88UHjV99hcATE44VddFxMQQ7Hb2nXpVrkzLufVimPxYlc)tH2RQWrk3CLGkOvuUssvvfIWUbtvPXQb2Dnu)6yvw(bCzcgrQcHt4sIIRsbJ4kkkivQcjvk5kYLX9g7HX3F4C3JDUp9S11eE)PUxMRX)yTpbfT3y(3p

The generated footer can be found in the sims linked below

To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. Go to raidbots.com
  2. Click on Gear Compare
  3. Use the simc addon to get a simc export for the character in aoe talents
  4. Paste that in Gear Compare
  5. Make Gear sets to compare
  6. Generate the export for the dungeon route sim with above weakaura from above route
  7. Paste the export for the dungeon route sim into the footer of the enabled expert mode in Gear Compare
  8. Run the sim
  9. Repeat all these steps on Droptimizer and on Top Gear to get an example of a supposedly working simulation

Expected behavior
Droptimizer and Top Gear end up at around 256k DPS depending on the Gearset. This seems plausible.
Gear Compare should end up at approx. the same number.

Real behavior
The Gear Compare ends up at around 164k DPS. Its Pulls last only around 10-20 Seconds.

Link a sim with the problem (if available)
Simulation via Gear Compare (bugged): https://www.raidbots.com/simbot/report/dsmCuq3mEkicu9DsRa1oGR
Simulation via Top Gear (working(?), normal DPS numbers): https://www.raidbots.com/simbot/report/9HGiThGNoabqYN195Yt7iu
Simulation via Droptimizer (working(?)): https://www.raidbots.com/simbot/report/tFvDy6mHKTYRBkSxe1iZMo

Character or /simc input
Attatched as txt file
# Moonflora - Balance - 2024-01-17 .txt

@mahranaka mahranaka added the bug label Jan 17, 2024
@seriallos seriallos added by-design and removed bug labels Jan 17, 2024
@seriallos
Copy link
Owner

This is an issue with your input, not Raidbots. single_actor_batch=0 is not what you want when a sim uses copy which is how Gear Compare works.

Be very careful about using Expert Mode if you are not familiar with reading/writing your own SimC input: https://support.raidbots.com/article/15-simc-expert-mode

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants