Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Add documentation what the Q-class abbreviations min.1, max.1 or group.1 refer to? #111

Open
kiryph opened this issue Aug 17, 2023 · 0 comments

Comments

@kiryph
Copy link

kiryph commented Aug 17, 2023

For degree = 2 output of Q_catalog:

abbreviation  degree  symbol  order  discriminant  zclasses  affine_classes  torsionfree_space_groups  con_classes_number  idempotent_number

min.2  2  1,1   1  (2)^1  1  1  1  1   1
group.1  2  1,1   2  (2)^1  1  1  0  2   1
min.3  2  1;1   2  (2)^2  2  3  1  2   2
group.2  2  1;1   4  (2)^2  2  4  0  4   2
min.4  2  2-1   4  (2)^2  1  1  0  4   1
max.2  2  2-1   8  (2)^4  1  2  0  5   1
max.3  2  2-2   12  (1)^2(3)^2  1  1  0  6   1
min.5  2  2-2   3  (1)^1(3)^1  1  1  0  3   1
group.3  2  2-2   6  (1)^1(3)^1  1  1  0  6   1
group.4  2  2-2   6  (1)^2(3)^2  2  2  0  3   1

Conditions:   degree = 2
Q_Classes: # 10,   Z_Classes: # 13,   Affine Classes: #17

IMHO, the used abbreviations, e.g. min.2/max.2/group.1 for Q-classes are not self-explanatory.

Apparently the first level sorting is done by the family symbol. I am not sure what the second level is.

Can you add to the documentation of carat and the help of Q_catalog what min/max/group and the integer refer to?

It helps user to make sense of it. I have no idea what group.3 or group.4 mean. What is enumerated (families) ?

I checked the existing documentation, e.g.:

and also corresponding publications:

  • Counting Crystallographic Groups in Low Dimension (2000)
  • Crystallographic Algorithms and Tables (1998)

and the source code of CARAT. But could not find any hint.

Only the family symbol f.s. $(d_1-\alpha_1,...,d_1-\alpha_1;d_2-\alpha_2,...,d_2-\alpha_2;...;d_a-\alpha_a,...d_a-\alpha_a)$ is explained.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

1 participant