We read every piece of feedback, and take your input very seriously.
To see all available qualifiers, see our documentation.
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
I've ported the sql/mysql/Oracle grammar to CSharp. I found that the grammar is ambiguous.
$ dotnet trparse ../examples/expressions.sql --ambig | dotnet trtree -a CSharp 0 ../examples/expressions.sql success 0.139722 (query (simpleStatement (selectStatement (queryExpression (queryExpressionBody (queryPrimary (querySpecification (SELECT_SYMBOL "select") (selectItemList (selectItem (expr (boolPri (predicate (bitExpr (bitExpr (bitExpr (simpleExpr (literalOrNull (literal (numLiteral (int64Literal (INT_NUMBER "1"))))))) (PLUS_OPERATOR "+") (bitExpr (bitExpr (simpleExpr (literalOrNull (literal (numLiteral (int64Literal (INT_NUMBER "2"))))))) (MULT_OPERATOR "*") (bitExpr (simpleExpr (literalOrNull (literal (numLiteral (int64Literal (INT_NUMBER "3"))))))))) (MINUS_OPERATOR "-") (bitExpr (simpleExpr (literalOrNull (literal (numLiteral (int64Literal (INT_NUMBER "4"))))))))))))))))))) (SEMICOLON_SYMBOL ";")) (query (simpleStatement (selectStatement (queryExpression (queryExpressionBody (queryPrimary (querySpecification (SELECT_SYMBOL "select") (selectItemList (selectItem (expr (boolPri (predicate (bitExpr (bitExpr (bitExpr (bitExpr (simpleExpr (literalOrNull (literal (numLiteral (int64Literal (INT_NUMBER "1"))))))) (PLUS_OPERATOR "+") (bitExpr (simpleExpr (literalOrNull (literal (numLiteral (int64Literal (INT_NUMBER "2")))))))) (MULT_OPERATOR "*") (bitExpr (simpleExpr (literalOrNull (literal (numLiteral (int64Literal (INT_NUMBER "3")))))))) (MINUS_OPERATOR "-") (bitExpr (simpleExpr (literalOrNull (literal (numLiteral (int64Literal (INT_NUMBER "4"))))))))))))))))))) (SEMICOLON_SYMBOL ";"))
(The main reason I did the CSharp port was to check for ambiguities in this grammar. All tools in Trash are in C#.)
Another example comes from the MySQL Reference manual https://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/8.4/en/select.html.
$ dotnet trparse --ambig -i "SELECT CONCAT(last_name,', ',first_name) AS full_name FROM mytable ORDER BY full_name;" | dotnet trtree -a CSharp 0 string success 0.2263846 (queries (query (simpleStatement (selectStatement (queryExpression (queryExpressionBody (queryPrimary (querySpecification (SELECT_SYMBOL "SELECT") (selectItemList (selectItem (expr (boolPri (predicate (bitExpr (simpleExpr (functionCall (pureIdentifier (IDENTIFIER "CONCAT")) (OPEN_PAR_SYMBOL "(") (udfExprList (udfExpr (expr (boolPri (predicate (bitExpr (simpleExpr (columnRef (fieldIdentifier (qualifiedIdentifier (identifier (pureIdentifier (IDENTIFIER "last_name")))))))))))) (COMMA_SYMBOL ",") (udfExpr (expr (boolPri (predicate (bitExpr (simpleExpr (literalOrNull (literal (textLiteral (textStringLiteral (SINGLE_QUOTED_TEXT "', '"))))))))))) (COMMA_SYMBOL ",") (udfExpr (expr (boolPri (predicate (bitExpr (simpleExpr (columnRef (fieldIdentifier (qualifiedIdentifier (identifier (pureIdentifier (IDENTIFIER "first_name"))))))))))))) (CLOSE_PAR_SYMBOL ")"))))))) (selectAlias (AS_SYMBOL "AS") (identifier (pureIdentifier (IDENTIFIER "full_name")))))) (fromClause (FROM_SYMBOL "FROM") (tableReferenceList (tableReference (tableFactor (singleTable (tableRef (qualifiedIdentifier (identifier (pureIdentifier (IDENTIFIER "mytable"))))))))))))) (orderClause (ORDER_SYMBOL "ORDER") (BY_SYMBOL "BY") (orderList (orderExpression (expr (boolPri (predicate (bitExpr (simpleExpr (columnRef (fieldIdentifier (qualifiedIdentifier (identifier (pureIdentifier (IDENTIFIER "full_name"))))))))))))))))) (SEMICOLON_SYMBOL ";")) (EOF "")) (queries (query (simpleStatement (selectStatement (queryExpression (queryExpressionBody (queryPrimary (querySpecification (SELECT_SYMBOL "SELECT") (selectItemList (selectItem (expr (boolPri (predicate (bitExpr (simpleExpr (functionCall (qualifiedIdentifier (identifier (pureIdentifier (IDENTIFIER "CONCAT")))) (OPEN_PAR_SYMBOL "(") (exprList (expr (boolPri (predicate (bitExpr (simpleExpr (columnRef (fieldIdentifier (qualifiedIdentifier (identifier (pureIdentifier (IDENTIFIER "last_name"))))))))))) (COMMA_SYMBOL ",") (expr (boolPri (predicate (bitExpr (simpleExpr (literalOrNull (literal (textLiteral (textStringLiteral (SINGLE_QUOTED_TEXT "', '")))))))))) (COMMA_SYMBOL ",") (expr (boolPri (predicate (bitExpr (simpleExpr (columnRef (fieldIdentifier (qualifiedIdentifier (identifier (pureIdentifier (IDENTIFIER "first_name")))))))))))) (CLOSE_PAR_SYMBOL ")"))))))) (selectAlias (AS_SYMBOL "AS") (identifier (pureIdentifier (IDENTIFIER "full_name")))))) (fromClause (FROM_SYMBOL "FROM") (tableReferenceList (tableReference (tableFactor (singleTable (tableRef (qualifiedIdentifier (identifier (pureIdentifier (IDENTIFIER "mytable"))))))))))))) (orderClause (ORDER_SYMBOL "ORDER") (BY_SYMBOL "BY") (orderList (orderExpression (expr (boolPri (predicate (bitExpr (simpleExpr (columnRef (fieldIdentifier (qualifiedIdentifier (identifier (pureIdentifier (IDENTIFIER "full_name"))))))))))))))))) (SEMICOLON_SYMBOL ";")) (EOF ""))
Ambiguity is a problem because it causes performance issues for Antlr4.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
No branches or pull requests
I've ported the sql/mysql/Oracle grammar to CSharp. I found that the grammar is ambiguous.
(The main reason I did the CSharp port was to check for ambiguities in this grammar. All tools in Trash are in C#.)
Another example comes from the MySQL Reference manual https://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/8.4/en/select.html.
Ambiguity is a problem because it causes performance issues for Antlr4.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: